Posts

Showing posts with the label 1985

AI Hallucination

Image
I've been thinking about how rumors might have developed and circulated in the Deadhead community because t he court documents give some evidence of how quickly word may have spread after Greg and Mary lost their lives. In Thomas v. Wong (C93-0616 MHP) one reads the following:  "[Megan] Barry left the Rainbow Village on the night of the murders to drive north. Id . at 561. She heard about the murders a few days later, from others who had left the Village and come up to Chico. Id . "Bo" was there when she first heard the news. Several people were sitting on his car, a gray or silver Scirocco or Rabbit, discussing the murder. Id . 562. Someone mentioned a newspaper article that said that authorities were looking for a man in a silver Volkswagen. Bo then told everyone to get off his car and left. Id . at 563." Von Wendel's testimony corroborates Barry's account because he related how the blond man who came to fetch his backpack was driving a Volkswagen wit...

A Hypothetical Scenario

Image
"A defense investigator spoke with Von Wendel on June 11,1986, after petitioner had been convicted in the guilt phase of the trial.  At that time, the investigator learned of the incident with Bo.  In the same interview, Von Wendel told the investigator of an incident in which petitioner had threatened a woman with a dog.  When Von Wendel intervened, petitioner left and returned with a machete."  ( Thomas v. Wong , p. 14) (The way I read this is that Thomas threatened a woman who had a dog--not that Thomas had a dog and he threatened the woman with it.) I want to critically examine the prosecution's argument at trial by considering a hypothetical situation based on Von Wendel's report. Looking at the incident in which Thomas allegedly threatened the woman, let's say that Thomas had had hacked Von Wendel to death with the machete after he intervened. And let's say that the police had arrested Thomas and that he was brought to trial. Would the prosecution have u...

An Alternative Story

Image
In this post, I want to respond to a question  someone  posed in a comment. " Everyone with half a brain knew what happened at Rainbow Village. This violent felon with a history of raping women at gunpoint -- Ralph "International" Thomas -- tried to rape that Deadhead woman. And when her boyfriend tried to intervene, he shot both of them in the head and dumped their bodies in the San Francisco Bay. And was convicted for that crime.  And died in prison where he belonged. Do you have anything to add to the story??" I have nothing to add to that story because I don’t think it gets at the truth. This is the story the prosecution used during the trial and it proved useful for convicting Thomas, who I think was guilty of having committed the murders. So I'd agree that it was a useful story, but I don't believe it gets close to the truth. The story told during the appeals process (and retold in the podcast) was meant to be useful for righting a wrong and getting Th...

Twenty-One Minutes

Image
Near the Site of Rainbow Village Reading through various documents yesterday I wanted to refresh my memory, and they reminded me of how imprecise the timeline I've given is. For example, to fit Jim Prew's account of when the party at his van ended (0200-0225) with Vincent Johnson's account of seeing Thomas with Mary and Greg, I've assumed that this encounter took place around 0230. I've assumed that it would have taken about 5-10 minutes for Johnson to ride with his friend down to University Avenue and that it would have taken him about 15-20 minutes to walk the distance between University Avenue and the entrance to the dump. I've assumed that Mary and Greg left the Village immediately after leaving the Prew’s van and that Thomas caught up with them before they walked by Cercy's car. Had they not stopped at the car, it would have probably taken them about 8-10 minutes to walk down to the dump entrance so I’m assuming it probably took them about 15 minutes to...

Eight Minutes

Image
Two Gravel Roads I wanted to visit Cesar Chavez Park to get a sense of how long it would take someone to walk from the site of Rainbow Village to the approximate location of where Mary and Greg were shot. I also wanted to see if I could find some indication of where the entrance to the Berkeley dump might have been, because Vincent Johnson testified that he saw Ralph Thomas with Mary and Greg near the entrance.  When I arrived I assumed that the terrain of the Park is very different from the terrain of the dump, but I also assumed that a section of what's now the Dorothy Stegmann perimeter trail roughly follows what was once the access road to the dump and to Rainbow Village. To get an overview of the area of the park I'm talking about, you may want to go to Google Maps and take a look at the satellite image of Cesar Chavez Park. To me, the park looks like a rhombus, and the side I'm focusing on is the east side of that figure. If you follow the Stegmann trail from the sout...

I Have Been to the Park

Image
My wife, Moonflower, and I flew out to San Francisco for the 60th anniversary shows this weekend, and today we took some time to go over to Berkeley and visit Cesar Chavez Park, where we picked some beautiful flowers to lay at the memorial to Mary and Greg... Some thoughts to follow in a separate post…

Just a Theory...

Image
Here's my theory on what happened in the early morning of August 16, 1985. At around 2200, a small group of folks (including Dan Adams, Robbie Van Heest, Chris Campbell, Paul Harter, Mary, Greg, and Ralph Thomas) gathered at Jim Prew's van, where they hung out for a couple of hours. Prew testified that, some time between 0100 and 0130, he left Rainbow Village with Thomas, Mary, Harter, and Campbell to get some more beer and burritos and to drop off Chris.   Greg didn't go along. As they returned, they saw Greg on University Avenue and stopped to give him a ride back to the Village.  Shortly after they returned to the Village (approximately 0200), Greg and Mary left the group to take a walk, and Thomas followed them. It's likely that the three walked from the Village toward the dump entrance, and on the way, they had to pass Vivian Cercy's vehicle. As they walked, Thomas decided to scare Cercy, who was spending the night in the car with her two young daughters. Cercy...

New Timeline

Image
Given the conflict between a key part of Vivian Cercy’s testimony and the testimonies given by others, I’ve removed it from my timeline.  Specifically, I’ve removed her claim that she saw Mary and Greg with a blond man around 0130 the morning of the 16th.  I take it as a fact that Mary was not in or near Rainbow Village at the time, because she and Thomas had gone with Jim Prew on a beer and burrito run from which they didn’t return until approximately 0200. **** Sometime before sunset, David Bergman ("Mousey") took Ralph International Thomas to the liquor store.   ( Berkeley Marina Murders , p. 134).  Thomas told Inspector Dan Wolke that Melody Medlin accompanied them. 1900-2000: Bergman claimed he heard a rifle shot at 1900  ( Berkeley Marina Murders , p. 134.)   Thomas Medlin claimed he heard a rifle shot sometime around sunset  ( People v. Thomas , p. 3) .    Sunset on August 15 was 2002. Thomas told Wolke that after returning f...

Did the Blond Man See and/or Hear Something That Night?

Image
Von Wendel’s Sea Space Station Moored in North Inlet Let’s assume “the blond man” didn’t commit the murders, and let’s also assume that he slept on Claus Von Wendel’s boat that night.   This raises the question:  “Did he see or hear something?"   Vivian Cercy’s  account of what she witnessed seems to overlap with  Von Wendel’s account of his encounter with Bo .  Cercy saw a blond man with a backpack and Von Wendel found what probably was a backpack on the veranda of his boat and a blond man fetched it later in the day. "Vivian returned to her original parking spot, down the hill, and prepared herself and her children for sleep. About 15 minutes later, she heard three noises that sounded like fire-crackers. About 90 minutes after hearing the noises, Vivian saw a blond man walk up from the waterfront, wiping his hands in the vegetation and the dirt. He had a backpack, and he either took something o...

Greg's Voice?

Image
I n the previous post  I  claimed that Mary and Greg probably almost certainly walked past Cercy's vehicle as they left Rainbow Village. Thomas testified that he did. Let's consider the possibility that Greg's voice was the " voice that sounded  white" that Vivian Cercy said she heard that night.  I've discussed how Cercy heard a voice that "sounded white" in another post. ( The 'White' Voice )  Here's the relevant section again: "[...]  Cercy heard two male voices, one of which sounded white, talking behind her car. The person with the white voice said, ‘Leave her alone; she's got two kids.’ A few seconds later there was a knock on the window of the driver's door and Cercy saw a man wearing a pea coat. He asked her name and where she was staying. [Cercy told the man she was staying with Harry Shorman.] When he asked what color bus Harry owned, Cercy asked the man why he was questioning her. The man said he was going to kill ...

Probable Location of Vivian Cercy's Dodge at 0230

Image
'73 Dodge Dart Swinger Where was Vivian Cercy's '73 Dodge Dart parked around the time that Vincent Johnson saw Thomas, Greg, and Mary? Of course we can't know its location for sure, but we might be able to reach a conclusion as to where it probably sat around 0230, August 16. Mary's family planted a tree and had a plaque placed near where they believed Mary and Greg had been murdered.  It's located near a picnic area at Cesar Chavez Park, close to the North Basin.  At the time of the murders, the landfill office seems to have been nearby.  A rough estimate of the distance between this spot and Rainbow Village would be less than a quarter of a mile.* Vince Johnson  testified that, on his way back to his bus, he saw Thomas, Greg, and Mary standing "next to the first set of cement pilings near the landfill office." ( Berkeley Marina Murders , p. 136)  Thomas appeared angry. The accounts Thomas gave to the police seem to agree with Johnson's testimon...

Rumors

Image
In the last post, I speculated that Weston Sudduth had heard rumors about Bowen being the murderer and this explains why he confronted Bowen in Herbert and Cauffield's apartment.  What had Sudduth heard? I can't say for sure, but during the evidentiary hearing, Herbert testified that in the confrontation he witnessed in September '85, Sudduth angrily asked Bowen, "How can you sleep at night?  How can you live with yourself?  Why were you washing your hands in the early morning in the bathroom?" ( Thomas v. Wong , p. 19)  The last question can be interpreted in two ways.  First, Weston saw Bo washing his hands that morning.  Second, Weston had heard that someone saw Bo washing his hands.  Clearly, the second interpretation fits my speculation. There's a connection between Sudduth's question and Vivian Cercy's testimony.  She testified during the preliminary hearing in October '85 that she saw a blond haired man washing his hands and hair at the sin...

A Nagging Question...

Image
There's a question that's been nagging at me:  "What was Weston Sudduth trying to hide?" I listened to Lindsey's "interviews" with him again, and it's evident to many people who've listened to the podcast that he was hiding something. Weston comes across as sketchy.   In Lindsey's last attempt to get an admission, Weston's position was "I don't know who they saw but it wasn't me."   He flat out rejects the testimonies of those who claimed to have seen him with Bowen the day after the murders, giving what I've referred to in another post as his "Rashomon explanation."  You know...five people can witness the same event and give five different accounts about what happened, etc.  Except, in his case, they all agreed on one significant point--Weston and Bo were together on August 16. 🙄 Let's go back to the ambush interview with Sudduth. Imagine him responding this way after being asked about what Robert He...

Vivian Cercy

Image
People's Park, April 3, 2021 First, I'd like to express my sincere appreciation to Venus in Style for sharing information about her biological mother, Vivian Cercy, in her comments to the blog.   For me, the stories surrounding the murders of Greg Kniffen and Mary Gioia tell about the various predicaments of those gathered at Rainbow Village on the night of August 15, 1986.  They detail the difficulties associated with homelessness, race, and gender.  For example, the story that Mary's mother tells in her book and the stories told by individuals who knew Mary around the time of her murder, shed light on gender issues associated with being on tour.  The stories Ace Backwords tells about Vincent Johnson shed light on issues related to homelessness and race.  And the two recent comments to this blog, along with some glimpses of her given Patricia Gioia's book, illuminate some of the risks Vivian Cercy endured as a homeless mother of two. In the comments m...

Vincent Johnson (II)

Image
Mount Shasta Over the past few months I've repeatedly put off writing this post because, although I had no problem admitting my ignorance, for some reason I thought I had to give an explanation for it. But I don’t; I just have to use ignorance as a starting point. Prior to a month or so ago, I had no idea who the underground cartoonist and author Ace Backwards (Peter Labriola) was, so when he posted a comment to the blog last summer,  I did not give the comment the level of respect it deserved.  For those unfamiliar with his work, Ace Backwards published Twisted Image in the early 80's.  He's authored two books:   Acid Heroes: The Legends of LSD , and Surviving on the Streets: How to Go DOWN without Going OUT.  He also writes a blog entitled Acid Heroes : The Psychedelic Sixties and Its Aftermath.   According to Wikipedia , he "sleeps rough on the streets of Berkeley, but is not indigent."  Kevin Fagan ,* a long-time reporter at the San Franc...

Questions For A Criminologist

Image
Imagine asking a criminologist to read through this case.  It would be interesting to ask them what they thought about Thomas's criminal record, his missing rifle, the lost corncob pipe, and the following details.   "A defense investigator spoke with [Claus] von Wendel in 1986 and learned of this incident. The investigator's notes describe the uninvited visitor as a White male but do not include the name Bo; they also indicate von Wendel recalled the name on the license as Bryan or Bryant. In the same interview, von Wendel also told the investigator of an incident in which Thomas had threatened to kill a woman and her dog. When von Wendel intervened, Thomas appeared to snap, left, and returned with a machete. When Thomas was distracted, von Wendel escaped unharmed. Chaffee made a tactical decision not to call von Wendel, reasoning that calling him would allow the prosecution to introduce this incident." ( In Re Ralph Intern...

A Reply to Dave's Comment

Image
La Vérité (Jules Joseph Lefebvre 1870) "...the truth is a rather difficult deity to worship because the only thing she does not allow her worshippers is certainty."    Hannah Arendt Happy New Year... The blog format I've chosen doesn't allow me to reply directly to comments,  so I'll have to reply by way of a new post to a comment Dave made to Flowers of the Field . First, I'd like to thank Dave for the clarification.  It both answers questions and raises questions.   For example, the court documents contain significant details that raised questions about the interviews in the podcast.  Did Dave live in an apartment with Bo and for how long?  The audio from the podcast didn't mention this.  But one document ( Thomas v. Wong C3-0616 , p. 21) states that Dave lived in an apartment with Bo and it  suggests he continued to live with Bo (in the apartment or camping) from February to May '86.  Did Dave live with Bo the entire time? ...

Flowers of the Field

Image
  Today would be Greg Kniffin's 56th birthday.  Tomorrow'd be Mary's 60th.  Flowers of the field... **** Here's something to consider.  All of the following statements could be true: The "other guy" may have said all of the dumb-ass things he's reported to have said. The police may have rushed their investigation and they may not have done due diligence by eliminating other suspects. Jim Chaffee may not have given Thomas adequate representation. AND Ralph Thomas murdered Mary and Greg. And, yeah, I realize there's a lot of "But-what-abouts" that can raised in objection.  "But what about Vivian Cercy's testimony?"  Vivian Cercy claimed to have seen Mary near Rainbow Village with Greg and the "other guy" around the time Mary was riding around Berkeley in a van with others, including Ralph Thomas.  And there's the "But what about all the conflicting claims Weston Sudduth made during the interviews with Payne Lin...

Fixation

Image
Over the past few weeks, I've been following the reporting on the recent murders of the four college students in Moscow, Idaho.  For those who don't know about this tragedy I'll give a brief summary of what happened.  In the early morning hours of November 13,  four students at the University of Idaho--Ethan Chapin (20), Kaylee Goncalves (21), Xana Kernodle (20), and Madison Mogen (21)--were stabbed to death in an off-campus rental house.  After just a month, this horrific crime remains under investigation by local and state law enforcement, and the FBI. Some of the reporting has included input from former law enforcement officials, including profilers (e.g. Mary Ellen O'Toole), giving their opinions about the case.  Much of this has been along the lines of careful criminal profiling.  Early on, some spent time talking about the murder weapon--perhaps a large knife--and they talked about the offender possibly having a knife fixation.  This got me to th...

Do. It. Yourself.

Image
  Home Grown The reporting in the first season of Dead and Gone stands in stark contrast and opposition to the story Patricia Gioia tells in her book, The Berkeley Marina Murders:  One Family's Story.  Ms. Gioia raised eight children—three daughters and five sons.  Mary Regina (named after the Virgin Mother, "Queen Mary") was the seventh child and youngest daughter.  In the preface to her book,  Gioia tells us: "After Mary's death, I collected countless newspaper articles, made endless notes of telephone conversations, and filled box upon box with legal documents, all relating to our court case.  It is an inventory of pain, with nothing discarded, because I promised Mary one day I would tell her story." (p. 11) Her book is a  self-published  work of love and memory.  Many Deadheads recognize "Do-it-yourself" as an important maxim in the community's traditional ethos, and will probably appreciate this work. Examples of Deadheads abiding ...