Posts

Showing posts with the label True crime

Did the Blond Man See and/or Hear Something That Night?

Image
Von Wendel’s Sea Space Station Moored in North Inlet Let’s assume “the blond man” didn’t commit the murders, and let’s also assume that he slept on Claus Von Wendel’s boat that night.   This raises the question:  “Did he see or hear something?"   Vivian Cercy’s  account of what she witnessed seems to overlap with  Von Wendel’s account of his encounter with Bo .  Cercy saw a blond man with a backpack and Von Wendel found what probably was a backpack on the veranda of his boat and a blond man fetched it later in the day. "Vivian returned to her original parking spot, down the hill, and prepared herself and her children for sleep. About 15 minutes later, she heard three noises that sounded like fire-crackers. About 90 minutes after hearing the noises, Vivian saw a blond man walk up from the waterfront, wiping his hands in the vegetation and the dirt. He had a backpack, and he either took something o...

Greg's Voice?

Image
I n the previous post  I  claimed that Mary and Greg probably almost certainly walked past Cercy's vehicle as they left Rainbow Village. Thomas testified that he did. Let's consider the possibility that Greg's voice was the " voice that sounded  white" that Vivian Cercy said she heard that night.  I've discussed how Cercy heard a voice that "sounded white" in another post. ( The 'White' Voice )  Here's the relevant section again: "[...]  Cercy heard two male voices, one of which sounded white, talking behind her car. The person with the white voice said, ‘Leave her alone; she's got two kids.’ A few seconds later there was a knock on the window of the driver's door and Cercy saw a man wearing a pea coat. He asked her name and where she was staying. [Cercy told the man she was staying with Harry Shorman.] When he asked what color bus Harry owned, Cercy asked the man why he was questioning her. The man said he was going to kill ...

Probable Location of Vivian Cercy's Dodge at 0230

Image
'73 Dodge Dart Swinger Where was Vivian Cercy's '73 Dodge Dart parked around the time that Vincent Johnson saw Thomas, Greg, and Mary? Of course we can't know its location for sure, but we might be able to reach a conclusion as to where it probably sat around 0230, August 16. Mary's family planted a tree and had a plaque placed near where they believed Mary and Greg had been murdered.  It's located near a picnic area at Cesar Chavez Park, close to the North Basin.  At the time of the murders, the landfill office seems to have been nearby.  A rough estimate of the distance between this spot and Rainbow Village would be less than a quarter of a mile.* Vince Johnson  testified that, on his way back to his bus, he saw Thomas, Greg, and Mary standing "next to the first set of cement pilings near the landfill office." ( Berkeley Marina Murders , p. 136)  Thomas appeared angry. The accounts Thomas gave to the police seem to agree with Johnson's testimon...

Rumors

Image
In the last post, I speculated that Weston Sudduth had heard rumors about Bowen being the murderer and this explains why he confronted Bowen in Herbert and Cauffield's apartment.  What had Sudduth heard? I can't say for sure, but during the evidentiary hearing, Herbert testified that in the confrontation he witnessed in September '85, Sudduth angrily asked Bowen, "How can you sleep at night?  How can you live with yourself?  Why were you washing your hands in the early morning in the bathroom?" ( Thomas v. Wong , p. 19)  The last question can be interpreted in two ways.  First, Weston saw Bo washing his hands that morning.  Second, Weston had heard that someone saw Bo washing his hands.  Clearly, the second interpretation fits my speculation. There's a connection between Sudduth's question and Vivian Cercy's testimony.  She testified during the preliminary hearing in October '85 that she saw a blond haired man washing his hands and hair at the sin...

A Nagging Question...

Image
There's a question that's been nagging at me:  "What was Weston Sudduth trying to hide?" I listened to Lindsey's "interviews" with him again, and it's evident to many people who've listened to the podcast that he was hiding something. Weston comes across as sketchy.   In Lindsey's last attempt to get an admission, Weston's position was "I don't know who they saw but it wasn't me."   He flat out rejects the testimonies of those who claimed to have seen him with Bowen the day after the murders, giving what I've referred to in another post as his "Rashomon explanation."  You know...five people can witness the same event and give five different accounts about what happened, etc.  Except, in his case, they all agreed on one significant point--Weston and Bo were together on August 16. 🙄 Let's go back to the ambush interview with Sudduth. Imagine him responding this way after being asked about what Robert He...

Vivian Cercy

Image
People's Park, April 3, 2021 First, I'd like to express my sincere appreciation to Venus in Style for sharing information about her biological mother, Vivian Cercy, in her comments to the blog.   For me, the stories surrounding the murders of Greg Kniffen and Mary Gioia tell about the various predicaments of those gathered at Rainbow Village on the night of August 15, 1986.  They detail the difficulties associated with homelessness, race, and gender.  For example, the story that Mary's mother tells in her book and the stories told by individuals who knew Mary around the time of her murder, shed light on gender issues associated with being on tour.  The stories Ace Backwords tells about Vincent Johnson shed light on issues related to homelessness and race.  And the two recent comments to this blog, along with some glimpses of her given Patricia Gioia's book, illuminate some of the risks Vivian Cercy endured as a homeless mother of two. In the comments m...

Questions For A Criminologist

Image
Imagine asking a criminologist to read through this case.  It would be interesting to ask them what they thought about Thomas's criminal record, his missing rifle, the lost corncob pipe, and the following details.   "A defense investigator spoke with [Claus] von Wendel in 1986 and learned of this incident. The investigator's notes describe the uninvited visitor as a White male but do not include the name Bo; they also indicate von Wendel recalled the name on the license as Bryan or Bryant. In the same interview, von Wendel also told the investigator of an incident in which Thomas had threatened to kill a woman and her dog. When von Wendel intervened, Thomas appeared to snap, left, and returned with a machete. When Thomas was distracted, von Wendel escaped unharmed. Chaffee made a tactical decision not to call von Wendel, reasoning that calling him would allow the prosecution to introduce this incident." ( In Re Ralph Intern...

A Reply to Dave's Comment

Image
La Vérité (Jules Joseph Lefebvre 1870) "...the truth is a rather difficult deity to worship because the only thing she does not allow her worshippers is certainty."    Hannah Arendt Happy New Year... The blog format I've chosen doesn't allow me to reply directly to comments,  so I'll have to reply by way of a new post to a comment Dave made to Flowers of the Field . First, I'd like to thank Dave for the clarification.  It both answers questions and raises questions.   For example, the court documents contain significant details that raised questions about the interviews in the podcast.  Did Dave live in an apartment with Bo and for how long?  The audio from the podcast didn't mention this.  But one document ( Thomas v. Wong C3-0616 , p. 21) states that Dave lived in an apartment with Bo and it  suggests he continued to live with Bo (in the apartment or camping) from February to May '86.  Did Dave live with Bo the entire time? ...

Flowers of the Field

Image
  Today would be Greg Kniffin's 56th birthday.  Tomorrow'd be Mary's 60th.  Flowers of the field... **** Here's something to consider.  All of the following statements could be true: The "other guy" may have said all of the dumb-ass things he's reported to have said. The police may have rushed their investigation and they may not have done due diligence by eliminating other suspects. Jim Chaffee may not have given Thomas adequate representation. AND Ralph Thomas murdered Mary and Greg. And, yeah, I realize there's a lot of "But-what-abouts" that can raised in objection.  "But what about Vivian Cercy's testimony?"  Vivian Cercy claimed to have seen Mary near Rainbow Village with Greg and the "other guy" around the time Mary was riding around Berkeley in a van with others, including Ralph Thomas.  And there's the "But what about all the conflicting claims Weston Sudduth made during the interviews with Payne Lin...

Fixation

Image
Over the past few weeks, I've been following the reporting on the recent murders of the four college students in Moscow, Idaho.  For those who don't know about this tragedy I'll give a brief summary of what happened.  In the early morning hours of November 13,  four students at the University of Idaho--Ethan Chapin (20), Kaylee Goncalves (21), Xana Kernodle (20), and Madison Mogen (21)--were stabbed to death in an off-campus rental house.  After just a month, this horrific crime remains under investigation by local and state law enforcement, and the FBI. Some of the reporting has included input from former law enforcement officials, including profilers (e.g. Mary Ellen O'Toole), giving their opinions about the case.  Much of this has been along the lines of careful criminal profiling.  Early on, some spent time talking about the murder weapon--perhaps a large knife--and they talked about the offender possibly having a knife fixation.  This got me to th...

"A Glee"

Image
  "A Glee" In the quote from Joe Berlinger I included in my last post , one might detect a note of glee related to the potential Berlinger recognized in the podcast's first season: " As a former Deadhead, lifelong music fan and crime and justice filmmaker, I thought I died and went to heaven [my emphasis] when listening to Payne and Jake’s meticulously researched podcast.  Dead and Gone  is an incredible weave of music history, social justice, and active true-crime investigation – three areas that I have been lucky enough to explore in most of my past work as a filmmaker." Let's not lose sight of the fact that two young people were brutally murdered on the night of August 15/16, 1985.  And let's not lose sight of the fact that a man was arrested for their murders, that he was tried for these murders, and that it's demonstrably the case that he did not receive adequate representation during the trial .  A jury found him guilty of first degree murder w...

That Ol' Green-Eyed Monster (II)

Image
In Episode 4 of the Dead and Gone  podcast, Gnome wonders "why anyone would be jealous of Greg" because "he was just a kid."  So let's return to jealousy as the motive for the murders .   Here, then, is the documentation this view: One witness testified that she had witnessed both Bo and Weston being verbally or physically abusive to women in the past."  ( Thomas v. Chappell , p. 7) Dan Adams witnessed an argument between Bo and Mary in which Bo seemed possessive.  ( Thomas v. Wong , p. 11-2) To Adams Mary seemed upset and afraid. ( Thomas v. Wong , p. 12) Mary and Greg began hanging out, becoming friends. "[Jim] Prew said Mary came into the Drop In Center at the University Lutheran Chapel on the 15th and after work he met up with Greg and Mary and several others.  They all went down to Rainbow Village." ( Berkeley Marina Murders , p. 135) "[Prew] again described the party scene outside his van; most drank beer but International drank whiskey...

To Stay or Not To Stay in the Bus…

Image
We know that, had Mary and Greg returned to Rainbow Village after their walk, they'd not have slept in a tent.  The city of Berkeley had established the Village as a place for the homeless to park their vehicles--hence why some refer(red) to it as "Bus Village."  There's a segment of the short film "Deadheads" ( posted on YouTube ) that may shed some light on pitching tents in and around Berkeley.  At about 4:32 from the beginning, an affable, and clearly resourceful man, talks about his homelessness: "I'm sort of homeless and I'm really landless.  I got no place to put my teepee, uh...in Berkeley.  I'd like to up in the hills in Tilden, or out on the watershed, and uh...or in the Marina.  But, uh it didn't work, so.  It's against the law.  And I just made this out of corduroy pants from the Free Box in People's Park .  And uh...it's a seven-foot teepee, and uh, all hand-stitched.  And a lot of the clothes I've made are, ...

Buses

Image
What potential leads could Chaffee and his team have picked up just by reading clips from  the local newspapers —e.g. the San Francisco Chronicle , the San Francisco Examiner , and the Oakland Tribune?   To answer this question, let's look at three stories published a few days after the murders.  The first one is "2nd body found in the bay area near Berkeley Marina" by Benny Evangelista ( Oakland Tribune, 08.18.85).  The second is "Execution killings in Berkeley:  2 Grateful Dead followers shot, dumped in Bay near bus camp" by Walt Gibbs ( San Francisco Examiner , 08.18.85).  The last is "Hunt for Clues in Berkeley Killings" by Rick DelVecchio ( San Francisco Chronicle , 08.19.85) Oakland Tribune .  Evangelista's story in the  Tribune leads off with this paragraph: "The body of a man who was visiting friends living in a Rainbow Village bus was found yesterday in San Francisco Bay near the spot where a woman's body was found Friday, polic...

This Post Brought to You By...

Image
The caption to the photo reads, "19 year-old 'Deadhead' Dan Reynolds sunned himself yesterday next to the one of the two buses used by the devotees of the group."  When I began writing this blog, I had a copy of a story with a caption to a photo, but I didn't have the photo itself.  This led me to form a very different image when I first read the caption. I'd pictured a young man, sitting in a chair, 'laying out and catching some rays.'  Relaxed.  But, the caption's misleading.  The young man's not sunning himself; he's sitting in the sun, on the hood of car, wearing a dark t-shirt and shorts, and it appears that a wind's lifting his hair off his shoulders.  There's a guitar sitting next to him.  Reading his facial expression, I'd say he looks stunned—like he's still in shock.  And it's understandable why he might be... Of course, this is the photo of Dan Adams that accompanied a story about the murders that the San Fra...

Aletheia (Or Verity By Another Name)

Image
Norman Garstin - "Alethea And Her Mother" (1898) A recent episode of  Dead and Gone (Season Two, Episode 6) finally touches upon a social issue that should've been addressed during the first season but wasn't—i.e. Reagan-era dismantling of social "backstops" and homelessness.  Still, it's been addressed in the second season, and that’s a good thing. Stepping back from the individual cases covered in this second season, one can see how they are similar in some significant ways to the case covered in the first season. In Episode 6, Mike Rooney talks to an associate professor of social work at the University of Buffalo, Elizabeth Bowen, and to a journalist from the San Francisco Chronicle , Kevin Fagan.  What both have to say about homelessness may shed light on the plight of some of those living in Rainbow Village back in '85, including Ralph Thomas and Vivian Cercy.  For example, Fagan makes an important distinction between 'real homelessness'...

That Ol' Green-Eyed Monster

Image
I think the "Bo Did It" theory sits on shaky ground.  How might it be put on a solid footing?  I believe there's a way to do this, and in this post I'm going to outline an argument that may help make the theory more plausible.  First I'm going to lay out my version of the theory. The Theory I consider Vivian Cercy's testimony to be the foundation for the "Bo Did It" theory.  During a preliminary hearing held in October and November of1985, Cercy testified that, in the very early hours of August 16, she saw three people standing near the gate to Rainbow Village.   The three people were a tall, blond-haired man, a dark-haired man, and a woman.  She overheard a verbal exchange between the blond man and the woman, after which the woman left the two men and walked in a direction away from Rainbow Village.  The blond man followed her.  About 15 minutes later, Cercy heard three noises that sounded like firecrackers. An hour or so later she saw ...

The Ammunition

Image
Let's assume that Ralph Thomas's rifle was the firearm used to murder Mary and Greg.   There are some challenges to making a compelling argument that someone other than Ralph Thomas killed Mary Gioia and Greg Kniffin.  It seems that the “Bo Did It” theory might need to demonstrate how following claims are true. Someone stole the rifle from Ralph Thomas's vehicle. It's quite plausible that someone stole the rifle from Thomas's vehicle.  Those in the Village who didn't already know he owned a firearm could have been alerted to this fact when International took a shot at Harry Shorman's Canadian flag.  During the time that Thomas accompanied Mary and the rest to go get beer and burritos, someone could have taken the rifle from the car without waking Tracy Scarborough, who was sleeping in the front seat of the blue Opel station wagon.  A broken window on the driver's side could have given them easy access. Someone only stole some of the ammunition Thomas ke...

Some Might Ask...

Image
A Spike Some might ask, "Have you tried to reach out to any of those interviewed for the podcast?"  I have.  A few months ago, I reached out to someone through social media. I began by asking if I'd contacted the right person.  I was told I had, and this person would answer any questions they could. I then sent a list of questions to them.  I've not received a reply. What did I ask?  Here is a list of some of the questions:    1. Did Greg know Bo before the night of the murders?  If so then how long had they known each other? 2. Did you know Jim Prew, Paul Harter, Chris Campbell, or Robbie Van Heest? 3. Can you think of anything that wasn't included in the podcast that should have been? Again, these are just some of the questions.  I've not followed up after sending them because it's not in my nature to pester people outside of a classroom.  People have busy lives.  And no, I didn't try to reach out to anyone else. Given that the ...