In this post I’ll try to walk a thin line between skepticism and cynicism with regard to the veracity of Vivian Cercy’s testimony . Some may mistake cynicism for s kepticism , so I’ll give a definition of skepticism, and then I’ll give a definition of cynicism to distinguish the two clearly. Skepticism is merely maintaining an attitude of doubt with regard to the truth of a claim or set of claims. Cynicism, on the other hand, is an inclination to believe that people are purely motivated by self-interest. So there are many reasons to be skeptical regarding the veracity of Vivian Cercy’s testimony, and these go beyond her claim to have seen Mary and Greg with a tall, skinny, blond man around 0130. These are reasons that prosecuting attorney Jim Anderson (a cynic, in my opinion) could have given a jury to get them to doubt the truth of her entire testimony. They explain why Vivian Cercy may have told Vincent Johnson that,...
My wife, Moonflower, and I flew out to San Francisco for the 60th anniversary shows this weekend, and today we took some time to go over to Berkeley and visit Cesar Chavez Park, where we picked some beautiful flowers to lay at the memorial to Mary and Greg... Some thoughts to follow in a separate post…
In this post, I want to respond to a question someone posed in a comment. " Everyone with half a brain knew what happened at Rainbow Village. This violent felon with a history of raping women at gunpoint -- Ralph "International" Thomas -- tried to rape that Deadhead woman. And when her boyfriend tried to intervene, he shot both of them in the head and dumped their bodies in the San Francisco Bay. And was convicted for that crime. And died in prison where he belonged. Do you have anything to add to the story??" I have nothing to add to that story because I don’t think it gets at the truth. This is the story the prosecution used during the trial and it proved useful for convicting Thomas, who I think was guilty of having committed the murders. So I'd agree that it was a useful story, but I don't believe it gets close to the truth. The story told during the appeals process (and retold in the podcast) was meant to be useful for righting a wrong and getting Th...
Comments
Post a Comment