In this post I’ll try to walk a thin line between skepticism and cynicism with regard to the veracity of Vivian Cercy’s testimony . Some may mistake cynicism for s kepticism , so I’ll give a definition of skepticism, and then I’ll give a definition of cynicism to distinguish the two clearly. Skepticism is merely maintaining an attitude of doubt with regard to the truth of a claim or set of claims. Cynicism, on the other hand, is an inclination to believe that people are purely motivated by self-interest. So there are many reasons to be skeptical regarding the veracity of Vivian Cercy’s testimony, and these go beyond her claim to have seen Mary and Greg with a tall, skinny, blond man around 0130. These are reasons that prosecuting attorney Jim Anderson (a cynic, in my opinion) could have given a jury to get them to doubt the truth of her entire testimony. They explain why Vivian Cercy may have told Vincent Johnson that,...
Given the conflict between a key part of Vivian Cercy’s testimony and the testimonies given by others, I’ve removed it from my timeline. Specifically, I’ve removed her claim that she saw Mary and Greg with a blond man around 0130 the morning of the 16th. I take it as a fact that Mary was not in or near Rainbow Village at the time, because she and Thomas had gone with Jim Prew on a beer and burrito run from which they didn’t return until approximately 0200. **** Sometime before sunset, David Bergman ("Mousey") took Ralph International Thomas to the liquor store. ( Berkeley Marina Murders , p. 134). Thomas told Inspector Dan Wolke that Melody Medlin accompanied them. 1900-2000: Bergman claimed he heard a rifle shot at 1900 ( Berkeley Marina Murders , p. 134.) Thomas Medlin claimed he heard a rifle shot sometime around sunset ( People v. Thomas , p. 3) . Sunset on August 15 was 2002. Thomas told Wolke that after returning f...
I n the previous post I claimed that Mary and Greg probably almost certainly walked past Cercy's vehicle as they left Rainbow Village. Thomas testified that he did. Let's consider the possibility that Greg's voice was the " voice that sounded white" that Vivian Cercy said she heard that night. I've discussed how Cercy heard a voice that "sounded white" in another post. ( The 'White' Voice ) Here's the relevant section again: "[...] Cercy heard two male voices, one of which sounded white, talking behind her car. The person with the white voice said, ‘Leave her alone; she's got two kids.’ A few seconds later there was a knock on the window of the driver's door and Cercy saw a man wearing a pea coat. He asked her name and where she was staying. [Cercy told the man she was staying with Harry Shorman.] When he asked what color bus Harry owned, Cercy asked the man why he was questioning her. The man said he was going to kill ...
Comments
Post a Comment